Recent experiments (Laufer et al., 1997; Rodriguez-Esteban et al., 1997; Tanaka et al., 1997) demonstrate that the apposition of dorsal and ventral ectoderm from the chick limb bud is necessary to cause the formation of an AER. When dorsal limb bud ectoderm was grafted into the ventral ectoderm of another limb bud, a new AER was formed in addition to the original one. It appears that at stage 15 (just prior to limb bud formation), the dorsal ectoderm is synthesizing a secreted protein called Radical fringe. As the limb buds emerge (at stage 17), there is a sharp demarcation between the dorsal cells that express the radical fringe gene and the ventral ectoderm cells that do not. As the bud continues to grow, the expression of radical fringe becomes restricted almost exclusively to those dorsal ectoderm cells at the dorsal/ventral limb bud border. These cells begin to express Fgf8, and they become the AER.
The importance of the radical fringe-expressing and non-expressing border is confirmed by studies wherein this gene is expressed ectopically on retroviruses. If ventral limb bud cells are infected with a retrovirus expressing radical fringe, a new boundary between cells expressing radical fringe and those not expressing it is created, and a new AER is generated there. Conversely, if the ectopic expression of radical fringe destroys the existing boundary between expressing and non-expressing cells, that region of the original AER does not form.
The formation of the AER may involve the interaction between the secretion of FGFs (such as FGF10) from the mesoderm and the boundary of radical fringe expression along the dorsal-ventral ectoderm border. The limited secretion of FGFs may be critical in localizing which cells along the dorsal-ventral flank of the embryo produce the limb buds. While it is still not known how the radical fringe
The formation of the AER may involve the interaction between the secretion of FGFs (such as FGF10) from the mesoderm and the boundary of radical fringe expression along the dorsal-ventral ectoderm border. The limited secretion of FGFs may be critical in localizing which cells along the dorsal-ventral flank of the embryo produce the limb buds. While it is still not known how the radical fringe expression/non-expression border and FGFs induce the formation of the AER, one possible mechanism involves the activation of Notch (Figure 1).
In Drosophila limb discs, Fringe will interact with Notch by adding a carbohydrate moiety to it (Brückner et al., 2000). This lessens the activity of Notch. A similar system might also exist in the vertebrate limb. Serrate 2, a ligand for Notch, is found in the AER, and mutations of Serrate-2 in mice form an abnormal and enlarged AER (Sidow et al., 1997).
The need for a dorsal-ventral boundary to form the AER is shown in two mutants: limbless and legless. In legless mice, the ventral ectoderm is dorsalized and there is thus no dorsal-ventral boundary. Wnt7a is found throughout the entire ectoderm. Similarly, the mesoderm is dorsalized by the Wnt-7a induction of Lmx-1. The AER cannot form properly in these mutants (Bell et al., 1998).
Chick embryos homozygous for the limbless mutation initiate the limb bud formation, but the AER fails to form. Recombination experiments show that the limbless ectoderm is unable to form an AER, even when placed on wild-type limb mesoderm. A normal AER can form when normal ectoderm is grafted to the limb field in place of the mutant ectoderm (Carrington and Fallon, 1988).
Although the phenotype of the legless chick embryo is difficult to explain (see Grieshammer et al., 1996; Noramly et al., 1996; Ros et al., 1996), at least some of it has to do with boundary formation. The limbless limb bud ectoderm expresses neither FGF4 nor FGF8. However, the limbless mesoderm expresses the Hoxd-11 through Hoxd-13 genes in a posteriorly nested fashion, along with the asymmetrical expression of BMP4 and Wnt5a. It does this in the absence of detectable sonic hedgehog expression or an AER. This raises the possibility that the lateral plate mesoderm already has the ability to express the anterior-posterior and proximal-distal patterning genes, and that this pre-pattern is subsequently stabilized, maintained, or augmented by the AER and Sonic hedgehog.
The limbless buds will form AERs and limbs if given beads secreting FGFs. Moreover, such beads induce Sonic hedgehog in the posterior region, showing that there is a polarity to the limb bud, even in the absence of the AER. However, the limb formed is a "bi-dorsal" limb, expressing Wnt7a throughout the ectoderm. This confirms that a dorsoventral ectodermal interface is necessary for AER induction.
The limb is a complicated organ, and new research makes it seem even more complex. There are several other genes whose function is needed in the formation of the AER, but whose role is not yet established. The limb deformity gene and the NF-kB transcription factor are both needed in the progress zone mesenchyme during the early stages of limb development (Kuhlman and Niswander, 1997; Bushdid et al., 1998; Kanegae et al., 1998); however, it is not known how their actions relate to the formation of the AER in the ectoderm. The analysis of development of the tetrapod limb has provided biologists with some of its greatest successes in understanding development, but it also keeps posing some of our greatest challenges.
Bell, S. M., Schreiner, C. M., and Scott, W. J. 1998. The loss of ventral ectoderm identity correlates with the inability to form an AER in the legless hindlimb bud. Mech. Devel. 74: 41-50.
Bushdid P. B., Brantley D. M., Yull F. E., Blaeuer G. L., Hoffman L. H., Niswander L., Kerr L. D. 1998. Inhibition of NF-kappaB activity results in disruption of the apical ectodermal ridge and aberrant limb morphogenesis. Nature 392: 615-618.
Brückner, K., Perez, L., Clausen, H., and Cohen, S. 2000. Glycosyltransferase activity of Fringe modulates Notch-Delta interactions. Nature 406: 411-415.
Carrington, J. L. and Fallon, J. F. 1988. Initial limb budding is independent of apical ectodermal ridge activity: Evidence from a limbless mutant. Development 104: 361–367.
Grieshammer, U., Minowada, G., Pisenti, J. M., Abbott, U. and Martin, G. R. 1996. The chick limbless mutation causes abnormalities in limb dorsal ventral patterning: Implication for the mechanism of apical ridge formation. Development 122: 3851–3861.
Kanegae, Y., Tavares, A. T., Izpisua Belmonte, J. C., Verma, I. M. 1998. Role of Rel/NF-kappaB transcription factors during the outgrowth of the vertebrate limb. Nature 392: 611-614.
Kuhlman, J. and Niswander, L. 1998. Limb deformity proteins: role in mesodermal induction of the apical ectodermal ridge. Development 124: 133-139.
Laufer, E. and seven others. 1997. The Radical fringe expression boundary in the limb bud ectoderm regulates AER formation. Nature. 386: 366–367.
Noramly, S., Pisenti, J., Abbott, U. and Morgan, B. 1996. Gene expression in the limbless mutant: Polarized gene expression in the absence of Shh and AER. Dev. Biol. 179: 339–346.
Rodriguez-Esteban, C., Schwabe, J. W. R., De La Peña, J., Foys, B., Eshelman, B. and Izpisúa-Belmonte, J. C. 1997. Radical fringe positions the apical ectodermal ridge at the dorsoventral boundary of the vertebrate limb. Nature 386: 360–366.
Ros, M. A., Lopez-Martinez, A., Simandl, B. K., Rodriguez, C., Belmonte, J. C. I., Dahn, R. and Fallon, J. F. 1996. The limb field mesoderm determines initial limb bud anteroposterior asymmetry and budding independent of sonic hedgehog or apical ectodermal gene expressions. Development 122: 2319–2330.
Sidow, A. and nine others. 1997. Serrate-2 is disrupted in the mouse limb-development mutant syndactylism. Nature 389: 722-725.
Stephens, T. D. and seven others. 1991. Axial and paraxial influences on limb morphogenesis. J. Morphol. 208: 367–379.
Tanaka, M., Tamura, K., Noji, S., Nohno, T. and Ide, H. 1997. Induction of additional limb at the dorsal-ventral boundary of a chick embryo. Dev. Biol. 182: 191n203.